UPDATES AND FEATURES
   
RELATED LINKS
The State of Art
The Best of Film: Directors
The Best of Film: Actors & Actresses
RELATED LINKS
World Wide Web

Internet Movie Database

Garden State
Rotten Tomatoes
Click here to donate
to Red Cross
+

Finding A Point
By J.S.B. Morse
Sept 20, 2004

Zach Braff and Natalie Portman in a bath tub
Miss Portman says, "Come here and give me a little smoochie woochie."

There have been many films that have attempted to capture the essence of a generation of youth. The Graduate, American Grafitti, Dazed And Confused all fit the profile and capture their respective generation successfully, though, interestingly enough, the last two films depict the previous generation in their youth. No generation film has broken the pointless slice-of-life depiction of youth though, and unfortunately a recent film has fallen just short of this as well.

Garden State is a generation film revealing the ambivilent, seedy, but often humorous lives of boomer children in an over-medicated society. The entire film leads to the final scene where the viewer is dying to escape from this ambivilance of pointlessness in meaning and what results is a common, everyday let down. This doesn’t, however keep this film from being one of the best films of the year with one of the best soundtracks of all time.

Zach Braff (of Scrubs fame) is the man behind the magic in this film and Natalie Portman is the breath of fresh air that we anxiously await for the first 20 minutes of smokey intro. Braff (writer and director) plays a twenty-something actor/waiter who is thoroughly unimpressed by anything. He dreams of tradgedy and lives a pointless existence with no color. His mother dies and he’s brought back to his childhood home, a place he hasn’t been in 10 years.

He reunites with old high school buddies while trying to avoid his father and continues his unimpressed behavior in the face of sex drugs and rock & roll. It’s not until he meets Samantha (Portman) that he begins to wake from his sleep. As he wakes up, he begins to realize that the bathroom cabinet full of prescription drugs may have just caused his long living slumber.

Portman is refreshing because she is youthful and uncorrupted and although she is not the ideal girl in the mind of many in search of sophistication, she is not tarnished like the high school buddies’ friends. The relationship between the two leads is well-portrayed, and believable, even considering the unlikely circumstances for their meeting. After some unique and funny scenes between the two the viewer is ready for point.

Zach Braff and Natalie Portman riding bike
When would we ever see classic shots like these if it weren't for independant-minded films?

The point comes eventually, but misses what could have potentially made this film one of the best ever. Although the writer/director/actor decides to shake off the things that make him numb to the world (i.e. the drugs), he doesn’t give himself a larger purpose than to just live. Some may think that that is purpose enough, but to live without purpose is very similar to the state of life the protagonist was looking to escape: pointlessness.

This could be scene as a first step in the process of self-actualzation, in which case, it would be a very successful first step considering the state of this overly medicated world. Unfortunately, I don’t see this becoming anything more than it is, which is a good generation film. To some extent, it looks to bring people back to reality, which is good, but to leave it at that ruins the potential.

The viewer would be grateful for just the slightest hint at a higher purpose, yet religion is mentioned, then quickly discarded, morality is ransomed and turned on its side, and the institution of family is reasonably scoffed at. Luckily, Braff did almost get love right, and if there’s any consolation, it is the hope for that ideal.

All in all, the film is well worth the 9 bucks. It is very well acted and well written. It is funny and believable. And perhaps it is fitting in this youth/generation film a grand purpose wasn’t found. It wouldn’t be right for immature kids to figure out the ways of the world. We’ll look forward to seeing what this generation can do when they’re in their thirties.


JSB Morse

the State of Art archive

   

MORE ON FILM
Best Directors, Best Actors and Actresses

MORE TOP FIVE LISTS
Best of Music, Best of Fine Art, Best of Fashion, Best of Literature, Best of Theater, Best of Architecture, All SOA Top 5 Lists

WHO ARE WE TO RANK THE BEST?
Our Judging Criteria

 

Film | Music | Fine Arts | Fashion | Literature | Theater | Architecture | Thinker

Communication Design
| Contact Us